Short drinks · Scotch whisky

Black Nail

Honey, heather and smoke in a heavy glass: that is the whole idea. Drambuie softens the whisky without masking it, and a slow stir over one large cube keeps the drink cold and strong. It is made for sipping at the end of the evening, not for rushing.

3.7Editors’ rating
Taste3.8
Balance3.7
Easy to make4.6
Popularity10
Reader rating: No reader ratings yet. Be the first.
  • GlassRocks glass
  • TechniqueStirred
  • DifficultyEasy
  • Time2 min
  • StrengthStrong (approx. 32 % ABV)
Jump to recipe ↓
Black Nail cocktail

Ingredients

1

Garnish: Lemon twist · Ice: One large cube

Method

  1. Add Scotch and Drambuie to a mixing glass filled with ice.
  2. Stir for about 20 seconds.
  3. Strain into a rocks glass over one large ice cube.
  4. Express a lemon peel over the top and drop it in.

Watch it made

Black Nail

Taste

Smoke and malt from the whisky, rounded by honey, orange peel and spice from the Drambuie. Strong, smooth and slightly sweet.

History and origin

The Black Nail is not a documented historical cocktail. Structurally it is a member of the Rusty Nail family, the pairing of Scotch whisky with Drambuie, the Scottish liqueur made from whisky, heather honey, herbs and spices. The Rusty Nail itself became a fashionable bar order in the 1960s and 1970s.

The darker name fits best when the drink is made with a peated, smoky Scotch, which pushes it away from the sweeter standard version. Treat it as a house style of the Rusty Nail rather than a separate classic: the ratio stays at roughly two parts whisky to one part liqueur.

Bartender tips

  • Adjust the ratio to taste: 3 to 1 for drier, 1 to 1 for a dessert-style drink.
  • A lightly peated malt is a good middle ground if Islay whisky feels too medicinal.
  • You can build it directly in the glass and stir briefly, but a proper stir in a mixing glass gives a smoother texture.

Variations

Irish Nail
Replace Scotch with Irish whiskey and Drambuie with Irish Mist for an Irish take.

Frequently asked questions

What is the difference between a Black Nail and a Rusty Nail?

Both use Scotch and Drambuie. The Black Nail as we make it uses a smoky, peated Scotch, which gives a darker, drier profile.

What is Drambuie?

A Scottish liqueur based on Scotch whisky, sweetened with heather honey and flavoured with herbs and spices.

How strong is it?

Strong. With no mixer it sits above 30 % ABV, so treat it like a neat whisky.

The perfect sound

Scottish folk rock

A smoky dram by the fire in the Highlands.

  1. Loch LomondRunrig Spotify YouTube
  2. Baker StreetGerry Rafferty Spotify YouTube
  3. Going Home (Theme of the Local Hero)Mark Knopfler Spotify YouTube

Rate this cocktail

Reader rating

Updated: