Brandy takes the familiar Manhattan formula somewhere smoother. Instead of rye's spice you get dried apricot, raisin and a gentle oak, wrapped in rich vermouth and a couple of dashes of bitters. A dark cherry at the bottom of the glass is the reward.
4.2Editors’ rating
Taste4.3
Balance4.3
Easy to make4.3
Popularity40
Reader rating: No reader ratings yet. Be the first.
Garnish: Cocktail cherry and lemon twist · Ice: Served up, no ice
Method
Chill a coupe or cocktail glass.
Add brandy, sweet vermouth and bitters to a mixing glass filled with ice.
Stir for 25 to 30 seconds.
Strain into the chilled glass.
Garnish with a cocktail cherry and express a lemon peel over the top.
Link copied
Watch it made
Brandy Manhattan
Taste
Round and fruity, with dried fruit, vanilla and oak from the brandy, dark herbal sweetness from the vermouth and a spicy bitters finish. Strong and silky.
History and origin
The Manhattan appeared in New York in the late nineteenth century, originally made with rye whiskey. Swapping the base spirit is an old habit: brandy versions show up in early bar books, just as the Martinez and Rob Roy grew from the same template of spirit, vermouth and bitters.
The Brandy Manhattan has a particularly loyal following in the American Upper Midwest, above all in Wisconsin, where brandy has long been the preferred spirit in supper clubs and taverns. It is not an IBA drink, though the IBA recipe for the Manhattan offers the same structure with rye.
Bartender tips
A VSOP cognac or a good Spanish brandy has enough body to stand up to the vermouth.
Keep the 2 to 1 ratio; brandy is already softer than rye, so extra vermouth quickly makes the drink sweet.
Use a quality preserved cherry rather than bright red candied ones.
Variations
Perfect Brandy Manhattan
Split the vermouth into 15 ml sweet and 15 ml dry for a drier drink.
Metropolitan
A similar classic of brandy and sweet vermouth, usually with a little sugar syrup and bitters.
Frequently asked questions
Is the Brandy Manhattan an IBA cocktail?
No. The IBA lists the Manhattan with rye whiskey; the brandy version is a traditional variation.
Brandy or cognac?
Cognac is a brandy from a specific French region. Any good grape brandy works.
Should it be shaken or stirred?
Stirred. It contains no juice, so stirring gives a clear, silky drink.